Same Drawing, Three Quotes: Why Fastener Prices Diverge

Why three quotes for the same fastener are not comparable: seven cost variables, a buyer checklist and the questions to ask before negotiating price.

Hex bolts and threaded rods in different sizes

Three quote emails

An RFQ for an M8×40 hex bolt goes to three suppliers.

The first replies fastest and cheapest. The second is a little higher and says the price includes a mill certificate and inspection record. The third is the highest, with a note: “DIN 933, class 8.8, zinc 8–12 μm, de-embrittled, export packing.”

Three quotes for one part — except they are not the same thing.

The hard part of buying fasteners is not beating the price down. It is confirming that all three suppliers are quoting the same bolt. These seven variables decide whether the prices can be compared at all.

1. Standard and thread: M8 is not the whole story

“M8” only gives the nominal diameter. Coarse or fine pitch, thread tolerance, full thread or part thread — each changes the process and the cost.

  • DIN 933 is a full-thread hex bolt; DIN 931 is part-thread.
  • ISO 4017 and ISO 4014 correspond to those two families.
  • A coarse M8 thread has a 1.25 mm pitch; M10 is 1.5 mm; M12 is 1.75 mm.
  • Fine pitch, left-hand thread and special tolerances must be stated separately.

If the RFQ says only “M8 bolt”, the supplier quotes a standard coarse full-thread part while the buyer expects a part-thread or fine-thread part. The argument starts with the first email.

Write: standard + thread size + thread tolerance + full/part thread.

2. Material and class: 8.8 is not a steel grade

8.8 is a property class, not a material specification. Two class 8.8 bolts can start from different steel grades and follow different heat-treatment routes.

  • Class 8.8: nominal tensile strength about 800 MPa, yield about 640 MPa.
  • Class 10.9: nominal tensile about 1000 MPa, yield about 900 MPa.
  • Stainless A2-70 and A4-80 are a different system; they are not direct substitutes for carbon steel 8.8.

The higher the class, the more the material, heat treatment and process control matter. A quote that says only “high strength” without a class and standard has not said much.

3. Heat treatment: the invisible cost

Heat treatment is one of the most underestimated parts of a fastener’s cost. It needs furnace batches, temperature curves, hardness checks and mechanical reports.

The same steel, heat-treated with different control, can produce a bolt that deforms under load or one that breaks. For high-strength, large-diameter or safety-related joints, heat treatment cannot be skipped.

Ask: Where is heat treatment done? Are batch records kept? Can mechanical reports travel with the goods?

4. Coating: colour is not corrosion protection

Zinc plating, hot-dip galvanizing, black oxide, passivation and zinc flake systems differ in both price and performance.

  • Zinc plating: good appearance, lower cost, suitable indoors and in light corrosion.
  • Hot-dip galvanizing: thicker zinc for outdoors, wet or coastal exposure, but it affects thread fit.
  • High-strength bolts after electroplating: confirm the de-embrittlement process.
  • Stainless steel: confirm passivation, not just shine.

“Zinc plated” can mean 5 μm or 12 μm. Those are two different products. Write the standard, the coating thickness and whether de-embrittlement is required.

5. Inspection: sampling, full inspection or a report

“Inspected” can mean many things:

  • visual check and quantity only;
  • dimensions and thread go/no-go;
  • hardness, tensile and torque testing;
  • third-party reports;
  • full inspection or AQL sampling.

More inspection and more documentation cost more. But who carries the risk of no inspection at all? Usually the buyer.

State the key dimensions, thread requirement, coating, quantity, whether a third-party report is needed, and the sampling level.

6. Quantity and packing: small and large batches are different products

Quantity affects scheduling, tooling, material purchasing and unit price. Packing affects cartons, pallets, moisture protection, labels and labour.

  • Small batches with many sizes: high changeover and sorting cost.
  • Large orders: material and production efficiency improve, but lead time and inventory pressure rise.
  • Export packing: pallets, shipping marks, fumigation and packing lists all cost money.
  • Mixed cartons, labelling and separate boxes look simple but are labour-intensive.

A price for 100 pieces cannot be compared with a price for 10,000.

7. Trade terms: EXW, FOB and CIF are not the same price

EXW is ex-works. FOB is free on board at the port. CIF includes freight and insurance. Comparing them is like comparing a farm-gate price with a delivered price.

Also check:

  • whether tax is included;
  • whether packing is included;
  • whether inspection and customs clearance are included;
  • when the lead time starts;
  • payment terms;
  • how material and exchange-rate movements are handled.

Align the trade term before comparing the number.

A comparison checklist

When the next three quotes arrive, ask these questions line by line:

ItemWhat to confirm
StandardDIN / ISO / GB / customer drawing, with the exact number
SizeThread, length, full/part thread, tolerance
MaterialSteel grade, mill certificate, heat number
Class8.8 / 10.9 / A2-70 / A4-80 and the applicable standard
Heat treatmentWhether required, where done, records available
CoatingProcess, standard, thickness, de-embrittlement
InspectionItems, sampling, reports, third party
QuantityBatch size, MOQ, lead time
PackingCarton/pallet/crate, labels, shipping marks
TermsEXW / FCA / FOB / CIF, tax included or not

A low price is not the problem; a vague one is

We have seen professional suppliers with low prices and expensive suppliers who cannot explain their standard. Price is not right or wrong by itself. What matters is what sits behind the price.

If one quote is much lower, do not celebrate and do not reject it. Ask:

  • Is the steel grade the same?
  • Is heat treatment included?
  • Is the coating thickness the same?
  • Is the inspection level the same?
  • Are packing and trade terms the same?

After those five questions, talk about price.

A final note

Buying fasteners is not like buying vegetables. Cabbage from two stalls is roughly the same cabbage. A bolt with a different standard, material, class, coating, inspection or packing behaves differently in the assembly.

If you have several quotes and are not sure how to compare them, send us the quotes and the drawing. We will not just say “we are cheaper”. We will help you align the ruler first.

Compare the scope before you compare the price.

Questions buyers ask

Technical library

Should the cheapest quote be rejected?

Not automatically. A low price is not proof of a problem, but it needs clear boundaries: which standard, material, finish, inspection, packing and trade term. A low price with unclear scope is the real risk.

Why do two quotes for class 8.8 differ?

Class 8.8 describes mechanical properties, not the steel grade, heat-treatment route, thread tolerance, coating, inspection level or packing. Steel source, process control, coating thickness, quantity and testing all change the cost.

How can I make quotations comparable?

Use one RFQ with standard, drawing, material, class, finish, inspection, quantity, packing, trade term and lead time. Ask each supplier to answer line by line instead of sending one total price.

Data & sources

Where the figures in this article come from

These are the standard or process claims used on this page. Articles on the same topic share the same claim IDs, so the same figure does not drift between pages.

  1. ISO metric coarse thread pitch is 1.25 mm for M8, 1.5 mm for M10 and 1.75 mm for M12. ISO 965-1 · Standard / traceable · Scope: Nominal coarse pitch; fine pitch and special thread specifications are separate.
  2. Property class 8.8 has a nominal tensile strength of 800 MPa and a nominal yield strength of 640 MPa under ISO 898-1. ISO 898-1 · Standard / traceable · Scope: Nominal values for the property class; actual acceptance follows the applicable standard edition and test method.
  3. Property class 10.9 has a nominal tensile strength of 1000 MPa and a nominal yield strength of 900 MPa under ISO 898-1. ISO 898-1 · Standard / traceable · Scope: Nominal values for the property class; actual acceptance follows the applicable standard edition and test method.
  4. Stainless steel property class A2-70 has a nominal tensile strength of 700 MPa under ISO 3506-1. ISO 3506-1 · Standard / traceable · Scope: Nominal property class value; confirm the applicable part of ISO 3506 and the product form.
  5. ISO 4042 is a standard for electroplated coatings on fasteners. ISO 4042 · Standard / traceable · Scope: Standard scope only; coating class and thickness must be stated on the order.
  6. ISO 1461 is a standard for hot-dip galvanized coatings on fabricated iron and steel articles. ISO 1461 · Standard / traceable · Scope: Standard scope only; coating grade and thickness must be confirmed for the part.
  7. High-strength steel fasteners that are electroplated can be exposed to hydrogen embrittlement and should be specified with an appropriate de-embrittlement requirement. ISO 4042 / ASTM F1940 · Standard / traceable · Scope: Risk statement; the required baking process depends on the product, coating and standard.

Data reviewed: 5 Nov 2026 · Next review: 5 Nov 2027

Related reading

Selection Guides

Have a drawing? Send it.

Tell us the standard, material, finish and quantity. We will confirm the specification before quoting — and tell you plainly if something does not fit.